Takeaways
-
Federal law safeguards the rights of nursing home residents. Despite this, similar problems commonly occur in nursing homes across the country.
-
Knowing your rights is the first step toward fixing problems when they arise.
Moving into a nursing home is often a daunting endeavor. Settling into the new environment can raise questions regarding rules and expectations.
The Nursing Home Reform Law sets standards for nursing homes, including skilled nursing facilities, that accept Medicare or Medicaid. This federal law applies to all residents in those homes, even those who pay privately.
Advocates at Justice in Aging, a national legal advocacy organization, report similar problems arise in nursing homes across the country.
Common Problems in Nursing Homes
Wrongful Discharge
Under federal law, a nursing home can discharge a resident for only six reasons:
-
unpaid bills,
-
no longer needing nursing home care,
-
needs that cannot be met in a nursing home,
-
threat to the safety of others,
-
danger to the health of others,
-
or the home closing.
Making complaints or refusing treatment are not valid reasons for discharge. The home must provide written notice at least 30 days ahead, explaining the reason the resident is being told to leave and how to appeal.
If you receive a notice, do not move out immediately. First, request an appeal hearing per the notice instructions. You are allowed to remain in the nursing home until the hearing is finished. Many residents panic and leave, but residents often win wrongful discharge claims.
Not Being Allowed Back After a Hospital Stay
A resident who goes to the hospital generally has the right to return to the next available bed. This remains true even if the nursing home has issued a discharge notice.
If a nursing home refuses to allow you back, you can take the following steps:
-
Check on bed availability often
-
Call your state's long-term care ombudsman
-
File an urgent complaint with the state inspection agency if the home doesn’t cooperate.
Less or Lower Quality Care for Residents on Medicaid
A nursing home may claim that Medicaid doesn’t cover one-on-one help or therapy. The law says otherwise. A home must provide the same services to every resident, no matter where the payments come from.
Therapy Cut Off too Soon
Residents are sometimes told therapy must stop because they have “plateaued” and are no longer improving with skilled nursing care. However, Medicare covers skilled therapy that maintains current abilities or slows decline—not just therapy that leads to improvement. Residents can ask the home to bill Medicare and can appeal a coverage cutoff.
If your therapy is ended too soon, ask your doctor and therapist to document why you still need care. You can then appeal the decision using the instructions on the notice you receive.
Restraints and Sedating Drugs
Physical or chemical restraints, including behavior-changing drugs, require consent from the resident or their representative. Staff cannot use them for their own convenience. If the staff propose either one, ask for their reasons and alternative approaches.
Ignored Preferences and Care Plans
Residents have the right to partake in their care plan and make reasonable choices, such as when to wake up or what to eat. Residents and their family members should attend care plan meetings and ask for specific needs and preferences to be written down.
Visiting Limits and Surprise Bills
-
Visits. Generally, residents may receive visitors any time they wish. An agent under a Health Care Power of Attorney (HCPOA) can restrict this right, as can a guardian, if the resident lacks capacity to make their own personal decisions.
-
Financial guarantees. A nursing home cannot require a family member or friend to be personally responsible for the bill. Be careful with “responsible party” lines on admission forms.
-
Arbitration. Nursing homes cannot require a signed arbitration agreement. If you sign one, you can cancel it within 30 days.
-
Undisclosed charges or unexpected bills. Charges must be transparent and agreed to in advance.
How to Resolve Problems
-
Use your voice, remaining polite but firm. Advocating for yourself and your care is good practice, not "being difficult."
-
Always make requests in writing. Name the problem, state your request, and keep a copy of all correspondence.
-
Use the grievance process. Every nursing home must have a grievance official and must respond in writing.
-
Call the state’s long-term care ombudsman. Each state’s long-term care ombudsman program service is free.
-
Contact the state inspection agency. It can investigate complaints and require the nursing home to correct violations.
-
Join a resident or family council. Nursing homes must give these groups meeting space, an employee liaison, and respond to their concerns.
-
Get legal help if needed. This can be especially helpful for discharge notices, hospital returns, and arbitration disputes.
Where to Learn More
-
Justice in Aging’s 25 Common Nursing Home Problems and How to Resolve Them
-
Medicare Care Compare for information about specific nursing homes

